Where’s the driver?

NHTSA tests Waymo school-bus fix after further violations

A recall query covers 2,895 vehicles after reports that driverless cars continued to pass stopped school buses after a 2025 software update.

The National Highway Traffic Safety Administration has opened a recall query covering 2,895 Waymo vehicles, examining whether a software remedy for school-bus violations worked after reports of further incidents. The agency is assessing a defect that could allow a driverless vehicle to proceed past a stopped school bus displaying flashing red lights or extended stop arms, even after initially slowing or stopping.

The query focuses on the adequacy of the remedy and the causes of incidents reported after it was deployed. Most of the reported violations occurred after November 2025, when Waymo said it had finished installing the update throughout the affected fleet.

The query follows Waymo's December 2025 voluntary recall, 25E-084, which covered 3,067 vehicles equipped with its fifth-generation automated driving system. The smaller population in the new query should therefore not be read as the original recall total. NHTSA's recall report put the estimated defect rate among the recalled vehicles at 100%.

Waymo traced the original problem to an Aug. 20, 2025 driverless software release that was broadly deployed in mid-September. The system could decide that remaining stopped for a school bus was impeding the bus or another priority vehicle, then resume travel before the bus's signals were deactivated or its stop arm retracted.

After identifying increased instances of vehicles passing buses with extended stop arms in October 2025, Waymo's Field Safety Committee authorized an out-of-cycle software hotfix on Oct. 30. The company deployed it incrementally between Nov. 5 and Nov. 17, then its Safety Board decided on Dec. 2 to conduct a recall. The revised software was designed to ensure that avoiding an impediment could not take priority over remaining stopped for an active school bus.

The original recall report recorded no collisions tied to that behavior, but identified 12 citations issued between Sept. 25 and Nov. 14, 2025. Austin Independent School District documented 19 distinct violations involving Waymo vehicles, including an incident in which a vehicle briefly stopped before proceeding while a student crossed the street. Public schools in Atlanta recorded six violations.

Separately, the National Transportation Safety Board said a Waymo-operated 2024 Jaguar I-Pace passed a stopped school bus that was loading students with strobing red lights and two extended stop arms in Austin on Jan. 12. After a remote-assistance agent replied, “No,” to a prompt asking whether the bus had active signals, the vehicle resumed travel while the stop arms remained extended.

Six vehicles passed the bus in that incident and no crash occurred. Austin ISD reported multiple Waymo vehicles passing stopped school buses during the 2025-26 school year, including incidents on Jan. 12 and Jan. 14. The NTSB's investigation into the Jan. 12 event and related Austin incidents remains ongoing as it determines probable cause and considers safety recommendations.

See also

All news